Paper Review Form

• Author(s):
  

• Title:
  

• Year:
  

• Publication Venue:
  

Generally, what is this paper about?

Specific problem being tackled:

Importance of problem:

Other attempts described and their shortcomings:

Contributions of this work:

New model, technique, or approach proposed:

Advantages of the proposed solution:

Limitations of the proposed solution:

Results presented:

Questions unanswered:

How novel is the work presented?

How strong are the contributions?

Grading Scale (Out of 5)

• 5 : well-thought responses
• 4 : clear understanding demonstrated
• 3 : reasonable attempt
• <2 : more effort needed
• 0 : no submission